| Date | Location | Result | |
| Apr 25, 2009 | Meadville, Pa. | Denison 14, Allegheny 13 | Box score |
| Apr 21, 2009 | Latrobe, Pa. | Saint Vincent 17, Allegheny 14 | Box score |
| Apr 18, 2009 | Gambier, Ohio | Kenyon College 20, Allegheny 13 | Box score |
| Apr 13, 2009 | Lyndhurst, Ohio | NOTRE DAME 12, Allegheny 10 | Box score |
| Apr 11, 2009 | Meadville, Pa. | Allegheny 17, Wittenberg 9 | Box score |
| Apr 09, 2009 | Lancaster, Pa. | Fredonia 15, Allegheny 9 | Box score |
| Apr 08, 2009 | Wooster, Ohio | College of Wooster 17, Allegheny 11 | Box score |
| Apr 04, 2009 | Meadville, Pa. | Allegheny 23, Oberlin 10 | Box score |
| Apr 01, 2009 | Washington, Pa. | Allegheny 21, W&J 17 | Box score |
| Mar 28, 2009 | Delaware, Ohio, USA | Ohio Wesleyan 17, Allegheny 16 | Box score |
| Mar 20, 2009 | West Palm Beach | Allegheny 16, Smith 5 | Box score |
| Mar 18, 2009 | West Palm Beach, FL | Holyoke 15, Allegheny 12 | Box score |
| Mar 16, 2009 | West Palm Beach | Keene State 13, Allegheny 10 | Box score |
| Mar 12, 2009 | Meadville, Pa. | Rochester I.T. 14, Allegheny 8 | Box score |
| Mar 10, 2009 | Meadville, Pa. | Allegheny 22, Frostburg State 14 | Box score |